Why Forensic Recruitment Can’t Be Treated Like Traditional STEM Hiring

At first glance, forensic science sits comfortably within the wider STEM landscape. It is degree-led, evidence-based, technically demanding, and constantly evolving. Yet when it comes to recruitment, treating forensic roles like any other STEM vacancy is one of the most common and costly mistakes employers make.

Forensic recruitment operates under a unique set of pressures that go far beyond technical competence. These pressures shape who can be hired, how quickly roles can be filled, and why suitable candidates are often far harder to find than expected.

Technical skill alone is not enough

In many STEM roles, technical proficiency can be assessed through qualifications, tests, or prior experience in a similar environment. Forensic roles demand more. Casework is evidential, not theoretical. Decisions can directly influence criminal justice outcomes, meaning accuracy, consistency, and defensibility are critical.

Employers are not just hiring someone who can do the work, but someone whose work will withstand scrutiny in court. That places a premium on practical casework experience, familiarity with forensic protocols, and an understanding of continuity, disclosure, and reporting standards. These are not skills that can always be transferred easily from adjacent scientific disciplines.

Accreditation changes the hiring landscape

UKAS accreditation and competency frameworks have added a necessary but complex layer to forensic hiring. Employers must demonstrate not only that individuals are qualified, but that they are competent within defined scopes of practice. This limits flexibility when hiring and often rules out otherwise capable scientists who lack specific, documented experience.

In traditional STEM recruitment, employers may be willing to train or upskill new hires over time. In forensic environments, the margin for error is smaller, and onboarding periods are longer and more resource-intensive. As a result, the pool of “ready-now” candidates is significantly narrower.

Security, integrity, and trust matter

Forensic professionals routinely handle sensitive material, confidential data, and distressing content. Vetting processes, background checks, and security clearance requirements are therefore far more stringent than in many other STEM roles.

Beyond formal checks, there is also an expectation of personal integrity and professional judgement that develops over time. Employers are understandably cautious, which slows hiring and makes cultural fit as important as academic achievement.

The emotional and psychological demands are often underestimated

Unlike many laboratory-based STEM roles, forensic work can involve exposure to traumatic imagery, distressing case details, and sustained pressure linked to case backlogs and court deadlines. These factors contribute to burnout and attrition, particularly among early-career professionals who may not have been fully prepared for the realities of the role.

Recruitment processes that focus solely on qualifications risk overlooking resilience, emotional maturity, and long-term suitability for the work. These softer, harder-to-measure attributes are often what determine whether a hire will stay and succeed.

Why specialist recruitment knowledge matters

All of this means forensic recruitment cannot be rushed, automated, or treated as a numbers game. It requires an understanding of accreditation, casework expectations, progression bottlenecks, and the realities of forensic workloads.

Employers who recognise these differences are better placed to attract and retain the right people. Those who do not often find themselves caught in cycles of short-term hiring, extended vacancies, or repeated turnover.

As demand on forensic services continues to grow, the way the industry approaches recruitment will be just as important as how it approaches technology or process improvement. Forensic science may sit within STEM, but hiring for it remains a discipline of its own.

We have been placing key candidates into the